The Brew Bake-Off Challenge 2019.

The Brew Bake-Off Challenge is back for a second time and the team did not disappoint. With prizes to be claimed and the infamous Wooden Spoon Of Shame to be won, 14 bakes battled for top spot once again. Cue lots of thorough tasting, fierce marking, and a passionate demand for a recount - what a way to spend a Friday afternoon.


Crack Pie - The Bake Off 2019 winner

Each bake was scored against four different marking criteria:

  1. Presentation - is it tempting?
  2. Taste - how're those flavours?
  3. Texture - is it light and fluffy?
  4. How does it taste with a cup of English Breakfast?

After some serious competition, it was our resident graphic designer, Halah, who's baking skills reigned supreme.

Inspired by a recent trip to Milk Bar, a bakery in New York, Halah made a 'Milk Bar Pie'. Made famous by chef Christina Tosi, this buttery and gooey pudding won the vote of the people due to its rich, yet salty and sweet crust. Irresistible.

As the 'Milk Bar Pie' came joint first in the 'Best bake with a cup of English Breakfast' category AND went all the way to win first place overall, we decided we had to share the Momofuku recipe with you all.


  • 115g salted butter;
  • 75g dark brown sugar;
  • 40g granulated sugar;
  • 1 egg yolk;
  • 80g strong bread flour;
  • 120g rolled oats;
  • A pinch of baking powder;
  • A pinch baking soda;
  • A pinch of salt.


  • 300g granulated sugar;
  • 180g dark brown sugar;
  • 12g Ovaltine,
  • 12g cornflour;
  • 6g salt;
  • 225g salted butter, melted;
  • 180ml double cream;
  • 1/2 teaspoons of vanilla extract;
  • 8 egg yolks.


  • 15g dark-brown sugar
  • 55g salted butter, melted, or as needed
  • Icing sugar, for dusting


    • 2 awesome Milk Bar Pies.


      1. Preheat your oven to 180C degrees.
      2. To make the oat cookie, combine the butter and sugars in a bowl and mix with an electric whisk for 2 - 3 minutes until fluffy and pale yellow.
      3. Add the egg yolk and beat for a further 2 minutes, until the sugar dissolves and the mixture is pale white.
      4. Next, add the flour, oats, baking powder, baking soda, and salt. Mix until the dough is fluffy.
      5. Grease and line a baking tray. Put the cookie dough in the centre of the tray and spread until 1/4 inch thick. Bake for 15 minutes, until the cookie has caramelized on top and puffed slightly but is set firmly. Cool completely. 
      6. For the filling, start off by mixing the sugars, Ovaltine, cornflower and salt with a whisk until they're blended together. 
      7. Melt the butter then add it into the dry ingredients and mix together for 2 - 3 minutes until it's moist.
      8. Add the cream and vanilla and continue to mix for 3 minutes, so any white streaks from the cream disappear.
      9. Next, add the egg yolks and fold them in so you don't add any air to the mixture. 
      10. To construct the pie, put the oat cookie, brown sugar, and salt in a food processor or use your hands to crumble the cookie. Transfer the crumbs to a bowl, add the butter, and knead to form into a ball.
      11. Divide the oat crust evenly between 2 (10-inch) pie tins. Using your fingers, press the oat cookie crust firmly into each tin. Use the pie shells immediately, or wrap in plastic and store.
      12. Put both pie shells on a baking tray. Divide the filling between the crusts. Bake for 15 minutes. The pies should be golden brown on top but still be jiggly.
      13. Open the oven door and reduce the oven temperature to 150C degrees. When the oven reaches 150C degrees close the door and bake the pies for 5 minutes more. The pies should be jiggly in the centre but not around the edges. 
      14. Take the pies out of the oven and transfer to a cooling rack then freeze for 3 hours.
      15. When you're ready to serve, defrost for a minimum of 1 hour then sprinkle with icing sugar. 

        Have your Milk Bar Pie with a tasty cup of tea. Shop English Breakfast Loose Leaf here.

        ‘Tis the Season

        December 2020. What’s in store for tea drinkers?

        Christmas FAQs

        You've got questions. We've got a list of all our Christmas FAQs to help you find what ...

        Why's the shipping as much as the tea?!

        All will be revealed...

        Becoming Plastic-Free.

        Last year, we set ourselves the challenge of removing as much plastic from our packagi...

        Festive Food Pairings.

        Ah, Christmas. The time for mulled wine and markets, battling other shoppers on the hig...

        Recipe: Chai Spiced Shortbread.

        If spicy, warming and sweet is everything you look for in a festive snack, this recipe ...

        Recipe: Earl Grey Brownies.

        Decadent, fudgy and rich, these chocolatey and subtly citrusy brownies will hit the spo...

        Recipe: English Breakfast & Marmalade Porridge.

        Looking for a way to seriously upgrade your breakfast on the big day but want something...

        Recipe: English Breakfast & Lemon Scones.

        We always come back to English Breakfast and lemon - whether it’s in our cold brew iced...

        The Brew Bake-Off Challenge 2019.

        The Brew Bake-Off Challenge is back for a second time and the team did not disappoint....

        Recipe: Chai Milkshake.

        This recipe is spot on for those with a sweet tooth. With a mix of vanilla ice cream, f...

        Recipe: Chai Latte.

        Our Chai Latte is the perfect balance of seasonal spices, slight sweetness, and velvety...

        The Tea & Chocolate Extravaganza 2019!

        Last year, we put our teas to the test against lots of different chocolates to see whic...

        Recipe: Cold Brew Lemonade.

        What could be better than a refreshing glass of icy lemonade on a hot day?

        Recipe: Green Tea Mojito.

        Fancy getting experimental and making your own super awesome Cold Brew Green Tea Mojito...

        Recipe: Fruit Punch Punch.

        You can make cold brew from any of our blends, even the non tea ones - hurrah! If you'r...

        Recipe: Earl Grey & Orange Iced Tea.

        Earl Grey is one of our favourite blends to get creative in the kitchen with, it's one ...

        Recipe: English Breakfast On Ice.

        There's nothing like a proper cup of English Breakfast made with 100% rolled whole leav...

        A Tea and Chocolate Extravaganza!

        Everything You Need To Know About Earl Grey.

        Everything you need to know about the awesome, flavour packed Earl Grey.

        Everything You Need To Know About English Breakfast.

        All of the requisite knowledge to become an English Breakfast expert.

        Afternoon tea: Not just for cakes.

        All of this talk of “the wackiest afternoon teas in the world” and “the perfect aftern...

        Recipe: Risky Whisky – An Iced Tea Cocktail.

        This winning cocktail has made it onto our snazzy recipe cards - hurrah! Print one off ...

        Loose Leaf vs Tea Bags.

        For us, this is an easy one.

        Recipe: Cold Brew Iced Tea One Liners.

        Short. Simple. Tasty. That's how cold brewing should be. Making iced tea has never been...

        How To Make Tea Ice Cubes.

        We've found a way to make Cold Brew more awesome, want to know the secret?  You'll need...

        How To Make Loose Leaf Tea.

        We’re here to show you how easy it is to make loose leaf tea, so you’ve got no excuses!

        Tea and Cheese Pairing.

        We decided to combine our two favourite things and do a tea and cheese pairing session.

        How Is Our Tea Decaffeinated?

        There are two ways to decaffeinate tea, and a clear winner.

        Recipe: Cold Brew Green Iced Tea.

        Here's a super easy recipe for delicious cold brew green iced tea. If you're into swee...

        Cutting Out The Middleman.

        Sometimes the only option is to take things into your own hands.

        Why Our English Breakfast Is Where It's At.

        The blend that we've got a seriously shameful soft spot for.

        How To Make Proper Iced Tea.

        Grab your notebooks, it’s time to learn how to make cold brewed iced tea like a true pr...

        How To Make A Proper Cup Of Tea.

        A proper cup of tea should never be drunk out of a jumbo Sports Direct mug.

        How To Make A Teabag.

        Hint: it's not easy.

        Proper Chai Lattes.

        Cinnamon at the ready - It's time to make Chai Lattes.

        Cold Brew Iced Tea.

        First launched in 2015 as ‘Cold Brew Lemonade’, we've revamped our Lemon and Lime Loose...

        Milk - First, Last Or Not At All?

        We're answering the eternal question and giving you a little challenge...    

        0 items